Restaurants in Shelter Island, NY | Shelter Island New York Restaurants

Barefoot Charlie's
85 N Ferry Rd (631) 749-1900

Pat & Steve's Family Restaurant
63 N Ferry Rd (631) 749-1998

Hungry Goat
26 Sunnyside Ave (631) 749-3130

Sweet Tomato's
15 Grand Ave (631) 749-4114

Two Eds Llc
3 N Ferry Rd (631) 749-0261

Virtual Cook
11 Grand Ave (631) 749-3577

Cannery Row Cafe At Alfreds
63 S Menantic Rd (631) 749-2516

Island Cafe
63 S Menantic Rd (631) 749-3355

Island Sweet & Treats
57 N Ferry Rd (631) 749-8862

Primo Pizza & Restaurant
53 Ferry Rd (631) 749-2732

Shelter Island Bake Shop
27 N Ferry Rd (631) 749-2717

SALT Waterfront Bar & Grill
(631) 749-5535